Tim
Russert: Prince
Bandar, welcome to "Meet
the Press."
Prince
Bandar: Thank you.
Tim
Russert: As I showed Bob
Woodward's book ["Plan
of Attack"],
January 11, 2003, you were
briefed by Vice-President
Cheney and Secretary of
Defense Rumsfeld about the
war in Iraq. That's two
months before the American
people were told. Do you
think that's strange?
Prince
Bandar: Not at all,
because at that time, the
options were either the
United Nations' solution
would work and Saddam would
respond to it or that it
would mean serious
consequences, which
ultimately lead to war. And,
you don't make plans the
night before you go to war.
It takes time to plan. And,
my country is next door,
there is 500 miles of border
with Iraq; and we were
interested to know what's
going on.
Tim
Russert: Is Bob Woodward
correct that you advised the
President to take $200
million and in effect buy
off the Iraqi army, pay them
for their service, buy their
loyalty, and that they could
be a security force right
now in Iraq?
Prince
Bandar: I don't talk
about my conversations with
the President. But, I
believe that would have been
the right way to go. There's
no point in Monday morning
quarter-backing now. What we
need now to do is make
things work.
Tim
Russert: In terms of oil
supplies, this is the exact
captions from Bob Woodward's
book, [on screen
display]
"I'm
worried about the
adequacy of the
oil market,"
the President
stated, expressing
concern for the
world market's
ability to absorb
temporary
shortfalls during
a war in the
Middle East. The
ripple effect in
the U.S. economy
could be gigantic,
and he asked about
the excess
production
capability of the
UAE and Saudi
Arabia.
"Saudi
oil policy could
be the saving
grace. According
to Prince Bandar,
the Saudis hoped
to fine-tune oil
prices over 10
months to prime
the economy for
2004. What was
key, Bandar knew,
were the economic
conditions before
a presidential
election, not at
the moment of the
election."
[Plan
of Attack by Bob
Woodward, p.324]
|
Senator
Charles Schumer of New York has
called on the President to
revoke your diplomatic visa
for interfering in the
presidential election
2004 by promising the
President that you might
lower prices before the
November election to help
his cause.
Prince
Bandar: So, what's the
question Tim?
Tim
Russert: Did you in fact
make such a promise to the
President?
Prince
Bandar: The president
talked with me for months
about the high oil prices
and how that could be
damaging to the American
economy and the world
economy as it is recovering.
And, I informed him of my
government's policy, which
is to maintain oil prices
between $22 and $28.
And, we prefer $25 as a
median. And, that is the
extent of that. That was no
deal on the election or
connection to the election.
And, this is not the first
time. In 2000, President
Clinton asked us to do the
same thing because prices
were getting to high above
$30.
Tim
Russert: But, in October
2000, crude oil was $35 per
barrel. So you didn't keep
your end of the deal.
Prince
Bandar: Well, there's a
reason. Because it's
not a matter of crude. The
reason you have high prices
in the United States is that
the refineries are not
enough to refine. There
is one million barrel
shortage of refined
products. So, even if
tomorrow, we send you all
the oil we have as crude, it
would not change the facts
here. The
United States has not built
a refinery in about 15 years.
Like our oil minister said
the other day in Dallas,
we're willing to invest in
refineries in the United
States of America. And, that
would really be the best
route to go.
Tim
Russert: What do you
think the price of Saudi oil
will be in October 2004?
Prince
Bandar: I wish I knew,
but I can assure you now
we've been working very
diligently to make sure that
the prices go down below
$28. This is a public
position we have taken, and
we've convinced OPEC to
agree with us on that. And,
I don't understand what is
so wrong with oil prices
going lower. I thought that
is good for America, the
American economy, the
American people. And, it is
definitely good for us in my
country.
Tim
Russert: And may be good
for George Bush's
reelection?
Prince
Bandar: It may be good
for anybody in the
Whitehouse and the American
people. And, we don't see
the difference.
Tim
Russert: Let me turn to
Saudi Arabia. Here's a
photograph of 15 of the 19
hijackers on September 11 [TV
display of Saudi hijacker
photos] -- all members
of your country. More than a
year - November 2002, after
the September 11th
hijackings, here's what your
interior minister said,
"We put big question
marks and ask who committed
the events of September 11
and who benefited from them.
Who benefited from events of
9/11? I think they [the
Zionists] are behind these
events." [Prince
Naif, Interior Minister,
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Al
Siyava-Kuwaiti Newspaper,
Reprinted in Saudi weekly
newspaper November 29, 2002]
Is
that the position of your
government?
Prince
Bandar: No. I don't know
in what circumstances this
quote was made, but I can
tell you the position of my
government and that includes
Prince Naif. 9/11 was an
earthquake. It shook us to
the roots. It's an evil work
done by evil people who were
targeting your country but
also targeting the
relationship between our two
countries. Otherwise, is it
accidental that they would
choose 15 misguided young
people to be out of 19 when
they had a pool of so many
people from so many
different countries? So, it
was intentional to do it
that way, to hurt our
relationship.
Tim
Russert: So, the
Zionists were not behind it.
Prince
Bandar: The Zionists
were not behind it, but
there is a reason why people
were skeptical. If you watch
the 9/11 Commission, people
could just not believe that
those young people who were
trained in caves in
Afghanistan could do
something so spectacular and
evil and sophisticated. The
truth of the matter, we all
were. Is it true that those
were the people who planned
it and executed it? Well, we
discovered later that it is
true.
Tim
Russert: Let me ask you
about September 13, this is
the way Craig Unger wrote
about it in The Boston Globe
and now his book, [on
screen display]
"..what
may the single
most egregious
security lapse
related to the
attacks: the
evacuation of
approximately 140
Saudis just two
days after 9/11..
"Let's
go back to Sept.
13, 2001..
American airspace
was locked down..
But some people
desperately wanted
to fly out of the
country. That same
day, Prince Bandar
bin Sultan, the
Saudi Arabian
ambassador to the
United States and
longtime friend of
the Bush family,
dropped by the
White House. He
and President
George W. Bush
went out to the
Truman Balcony for
a private
conversation.
"..the
Saudis themselves
say that Prince
Bandar was trying
to orchestrate the
evacuation of
scores of Saudis
from the United
States despite the
lockdown on air
travel.
"Meanwhile,
a small plane in
Tampa, Fla. took
off for Lexington,
Ky. According to
former Tampa cop
Dan Grossi and
former FBI agent
Manny Perez, who
were on the flight
to provide
security, the
passengers
included three
young Saudis..
"The
plane taking off
from Tampa was the
first of at least
eight aircraft
that began flying
across the
country, stopping
in at least 12
American cities
and carrying at
least 140
passengers out of
the country over
the next week or
so.. About 24 of
them were members
of the bin Laden
family." [Boston
Globe, Craig
Unger, April 11,
2004]
|
Did
you talk to President Bush
about allowing those Saudi
citizens to go home?
Prince
Bandar: No.
Tim
Russert: You never
brought it up?
Prince
Bandar: Period.
But, if you allow me Tim, my
only comment about this book
and the quote you just read
to me - in French, it's
hogwash, number one. Number
two - the 9/11 Commission
just declared -- let me read
to you what they declared. The
9/11 Commission released a
statement that says the FBI
concluded that nobody,
nobody was allowed to depart
on these six flights who the
FBI wanted to interview in
connection with 9/11 attacks
or who the FBI later
concluded had any
involvement in the attack.
The statement also says that
the Saudi flights were
screened by law enforcement
officials primarily, but
also FBI, to ensure that
people on these flights did
not pose a threat to the
national security. And,
nobody of interest to the
FBI with regard to 9/11
investigation was allowed to
leave the country.
The
tragedy here, Tim, is that
there are people who don't
know how to take
"yes" for an
answer. The 9/11 Commission
says this, the FBI says
this, and you still get
people coming up with books
that say that they smuggled
them.
Tim
Russert: But Prince,
here's the question. This is
a photograph of you with the
President down at his
Crawford Ranch. He brought
his family. [Photo of
Bush and Bandar at ranch
shown; August 27, 2002]
Elsa Walsh of the New Yorker
wrote that you are almost a
member of the Bush family.
That was her interpretation
of it after doing an
enormous amount of research.
And, 140 did leave the
United States when Americans
couldn't fly. The FBI
spokesman, Johnny Norelli
said I can say unequivocally
that the FBI had no role in
facilitating these flights.
Jim Thompson on the 9/11
Commission asked Richard
Armitage, Deputy Secretary
of State, did you, the State
Department authorize this?
"No sir." I asked
the Vice-President of the
United States on this
program, did he know
anything about it? "No
sir." 140 Saudis leave
the country, two days after
September 11, and nobody
knows who gave permission.
You don't know anything
about it? You didn't ask
anyone for permission? You
didn't facilitate it in any
way? The planes were just
allowed..
Prince
Bandar: Tim, no, no, no.
This is becoming exotic now.
We had those people in the
country, and a lot of them
were relatives of the bin
Laden family going to
school, from teenagers to
some people in college. And
we asked the FBI, that those
people are scattered all
over America and with
tempers high at that time,
and rightly so, and we were
worried that someone getting
emotional would hurt them.
Tim
Russert: So, who did you
call for permission?
Prince
Bandar: We didn't call
them, we asked them, is it
possible..
Tim
Russert: Who?
Prince
Bandar: The FBI..
Tim
Russert: You called the
FBI, and they gave
permission?
Prince
Bandar: The FBI and I
called them to Richard
Clarke, in his testimony,
called him and he said I
have no problem if the FBI
has no problem. So, we
gathered them all in here
and then once they were
here, they left. Now, the
other airplanes were for
Saudi officials who were
here on vacation. And, after
this disaster took place,
they all had to go back home
to official positions. But,
it is not true that they
were flying when Americans
were not flying, Tim.
Americans were flying, and
restrictions were lifted. I
mean, the stoppage was
lifted, but there were
restrictions. So, think
about it logically. Do you
think.. where are we, in a
"banana republic"
where I would take 148
Saudis and put them in an
aircraft and smuggle them
out, and nobody would know?
Look, people have to take
"yes" for an
answer and read
what the 9/11 Commission
said on this.
Tim
Russert: Let me turn to
the whole issue of terrorism
and the funding of it. This
is Newsweek Magazine,
headline "New Questions
about Saudi Money - And
Bandar." [on
screen display]
"A
federal
investigation into
the back accounts
of the Saudi
Embassy in
Washington has
identified more
that $27 million
in 'suspicious'
transactions-including
hundreds of
thousands of
dollars paid to
Muslim charities,
and to clerics and
Saudi students who
are being
scrutinized for
possible links to
terrorist
activity,
according to
government
documents. ..The
probe also has
uncovered large
wire transfers
overseas by the
Saudi ambassador
to the United
States, Prince
Bandar bin Sultan.
The transactions
recently prompted
the Saudi
Embassy's longtime
bank, the Riggs
Bank .. to drop
the Saudis as a
client after the
embassy officials
were 'unable to
provide an
explanation that
was satisfying,'
says a source
familiar with the
discussions."
[Newsweek
Magazine, Michael
Isikoff/April 12,
2004]
|
Prince
Bandar: Tim, if that was
true, I think it would make
a great movie, but it's not
true. We terminated.. Riggs
Bank problem is a regulation
problem that has nothing to
do with Saudi Arabia.
However, Riggs Bank and us
came to mutual agreement to
terminate our relationship.
As
far as the embassy's
accounts, or my wife's
account, or my account,
there is not one question
that we had from the U.S.
government about what
happened to these accounts.
Here's the problem - when a
story like this, that has a
prince, princess, money,
terrorism - it is exotic.
The tragedy I find.. I like
this country, and I like the
American people, they are
fair people. But, one thing
that is done in this country
that really disappoints me,
and I could say something
stronger, is that when
someone puts a story like
that, like what Newsweek
did, it's a big story. The
two people that started all
this, Mr. Basnan and
Bayoumi.. A
month ago, the FBI came and
after two years of
investigation, there is no
connection or foul play.
Guess what? How many times
did you make a special
program about or Newsweek
have an announcement? They
didn't.
Tim
Russert: Prince, the
former general counsel to
the Department of Treasury,
David Aufhauser, a
professional, a lawyer,
testifying under oath before
the Senate Judiciary
Committee, [on screen
display]
"Question:
With regard to the
trail of money..
and whether it
leads in some
cases to Saudi
Arabia? Aufhauser:
In many cases it
is the epicenter.
Question: And does
that trail of
money also show
money going to al
Qaeda? Aufhauser:
Yes. Question: Is
the money from
Saudi Arabia a
significant source
of funding for
terrorism
generally?
Aufhauser: Yes.
Principally al
Qaeda but many
other recipients
as well." [David
D. Aufhauser,
General Counsel,
Dept. of Treasury,
Testimony to
Senate Judiciary
Cmte., June 26,
2003]
|
This
was the scene in April 2002,
when your king, a state
sponsored telethon, and look
at these pictures, [TV
footage of telethon shown -
April 11, 2002] raised
over $92 million, and the
money was for quote
"Palestinian
martyrs," suicide
bombers who blew up Israeli
children, school buses,
restaurants. Here's the
Treasury Department of the
United States saying that
Saudi money is funding al
Qaeda. You're having
telethons raising money for
Palestinian suicide bombers,
and you sit here and say,
how could people say these
terrible things about us?
Prince
Bandar: Yes, I say that
very easily because nothing
stands still. If you are
saying that before 9/11, we
didn't have our thing
together - yes. But, nor did
you. Look what 9/11 is
showing. However, since..
Tim
Russert: But this was
April 2002..
Prince
Bandar: I know, but
since then, since 9/11,
after we recovered from the
shock, we looked at all our
procedures. We have come
through, and we are proud of
it.
You
read to me a quote, let me
read to you the same man in
a hearing afterwards, saying
the exactly the opposite to
this. Secretary
Snow publicly in Saudi
Arabia and in a briefing
here, says the opposite
to that.. the Financial
Action Task Force of the
Organization of the Economic
Cooperation and Development
(OECD) just came out with a
report in March. It
says, in the area of
charitable giving, new
regulations to crackdown on
abuses at Saudi
Arabian-based charities
probably go further than any
country in the world. This
is done by the G7.
Tim
Russert: Here is the
perception amongst many
Americans. That the Saudis,
and many members in
Congress, you've talked with
them as well as I have, the
Saudis play a double game.
They open up the spigot and
say it's all right to vent
your hostilities towards the
United States, just leave us
in the monarchy alone. But
now, the genie's out of the
bottle. But, the problem is
how did people develop such
hostile attitudes towards
the United States? A
commission was create by
Congress, and here is the
report from May 2003, the
U.S. Commission on
International Religious
Freedom. [on screen display]
"Independent
studies conducted
in recent months
indicate that
official
government
textbooks,
published by the
Saudi Ministry of
Education, include
offensive and
discriminatory
language and, in
some cases,
promote
intolerance and
hatred of other
religious groups.
Among the major
findings of these
studies of the
Saudi public
education system
are:
"(1) Islam -
specifically the
Wahhabi
interpretation -
is presented as
the only true
religion and all
other religions
are considered
invalid and
misguided,
including other
streams of Islam..
"(2)
Christians and
Jews repeatedly
are labeled as
infidels and
enemies of Islam
who should not be
befriended or
emulated, and are
referred to in
eighth grade
textbooks as
'apes' and 'pigs;'
"(3) Jews are
repeatedly
referred to as a
'wicked nation,'
characterized by
bribery,
deception, and
betrayal, among
other things;
"(4) those
who abandon Islam
for another
religion deserve
to be killed, or
at least
imprisoned, if
found
guilty.."
[U.S.
Commission on
International
Religious Freedom,
Report on Saudi
Arabia, May 2003]
|
If
you teach your kids that in
Saudi Arabia and in the
madrassahs around the world,
of course they're going to
hate the United States and
Israel. In January 2004, 16
employees of your embassy
had their diplomatic visas
revoked, why? Because
they were teaching at the
Institute for Islamic and
Arabic Services over in
Virginia. And, our
government said we had to
protect our homeland and
remove them from our
country. That's the reality.
Prince
Bandar: That's not true
Tim. If it was the reality,
then I don't blame the
American people to hate us,
but that is not the reality.
Those people you were
talking about, the 14
people, were teachers in
this institute. They were on
the diplomatic list of the
embassy for 15 years. The
law has changed the State
Department said to change
their visas. So, we had to
send them home so they can
change their visa, so they
can come on a different
visa. That's all that
happened there.
Tim
Russert: Here's your own
newspaper, the Arab
News editorial. This
is terribly important..
Prince
Bandar: I agree with
you. Let me comment on.. You
read me a long.. charges or
comments from Congress and
the reports. If that was
true, then of course our
people should hate America,
but go
to the Zogby poll that he
did. And, if you look at
that polling, you will find
how different the reality is
there from what the
congressional report says.
As
far as our education is
concerned, we went and
looked.. Look Tim, after
9/11, we were shaken to our
roots. It was an earthquake
for us. It took us a long
time to come out of that
shock and say to ourselves,
"What happened? What
happened?" So, when we
looked at our educational
system.. here are the
statistics. We found 85% of
the material was acceptable.
We found 10% was
questionable, meaning it
could go either way
depending on the teacher. We
found 5% was objectionable.
What did we do? We cleared
the 5%, and we made sure
that the 10% that is
questionable becomes much
less prone to be misused,
and action was taken. It is
difficult for people to keep
repeating things that
happened and, corrective
action was taken.
Tim
Russert: The Arab
News paper in your
country, editorial,
"But so to has the
chattering, malicious,
vindictive, hate propaganda,
that has provided a fertile
ground for ignorance and
hatred to grow." Here's
the Washington Post, not
before September 11.."
Prince
Bandar: What was the
point of that Arabic paper
though?
Tim
Russert: This is from
this past Wednesday,
headline, "U.S.-Saudi
Relations Show Signs of
Stress - Reformers Labeled
'Agents of America.' This is
last Wednesday. [Excerpt
of article shown on screen]
Reformers in your
government, according to
Prince Naif, were agents of
America. And, they were
arrested. Three are still in
prison.
Prince
Bandar: Right.
Tim
Russert: What does that
tell us about your country?
Prince
Bandar: Well, if you let
me answer, I will tell you.
Number one - when you talk
about the one before that
Arabic paper, you were
saying they were saying bad
things about American
Christians and so on. Look,
have you heard what some of
the Evangelical priests say
here about Islam and our
prophet. We all have our
cuckoos, and they all
sometimes say the wrong
thing.
Tim
Russert: But, this is
the Minister of the
Interior?
Prince
Bandar: No, no, I'm
talking about the one from
before when you said people
were saying these bad things
about Christians, pigs, etc.
There's a rabbi in Israel
who said those Arabs are
snakes, and they should be
gotten rid of. I cannot
speak for everyone in my
country, and you cannot
speak for everyone in your
country. If you want to take
what the papers says then
by-golly, I wish you get
half of what we get in your
news media as in our media.
Now, as far as the Minister
of Interior, Prince Naif,
with the statements you
made, I don't know what
context it is. If I knew, I
could answer you.
But,
John
Zogby made the polling that
showed that 91% of Saudis
said they liked America. And
95% said they are against
bin Laden, and they don't
think what he did is right.
Tim
Russert: Ok, we're out
of time. One simple
question. Who's more popular
in your country, Osama bin
Laden or George W. Bush?
Prince
Bandar: We never put
that polling there.
Tim
Russert: President
Mubarak of Egypt said that
the hatred of America is
unprecedented in the Arab
world.
Prince
Bandar: I make it a
habit not to comment on
heads of states' comments.
But, I'm telling you about
Saudi Arabia.
Saudi
Arabia, the
majority of the people, over
90%, don't hate Americans.
Now, if you insist that they
hate America, that I cannot
help you with.
Finally,
I would like to make a
comment about Senator
Schumer. Senator Schumer is
really a much nicer person
when I meet with him in
private than he is on TV.
And secondly, make your
words soft and sweet, you
never know when you have to
eat them.
Saudi
Arabia is a friend of yours
for 60 years, and it will
continue to be. We are the
targets for the same enemy. The
bombing in Riyadh three days
ago was not done by
Irish people. It was the
same people who blew up
9/11.
So,
you cannot tell us we are
dealing with the devil. We
declared war on those bad
people, and we're going to
get them.
Tim
Russert: Thanks for
sharing your views. I hope
you come back again.
Prince
Bandar: Thanks, Tim.
|